Grammatical Relationships: Pronouns
Not sure you’re ready?
Take the ~3-minute readiness diagnostic and see where you stand.
Language is an engineering discipline; its load-bearing structures are nouns, and its highly efficient, lightweight replacement parts are pronouns. In the high-stakes environment of education—whether you are drafting a legally binding Individualized Education Program (IEP), communicating complex policies to parents, or modeling standard English for a classroom of observant students—the structural integrity of your sentences is paramount. If you install the wrong replacement part, or if that part does not seamlessly fit the mechanism it is designed to support, the communication collapses. Grammatical errors in professional prose do not just confuse the reader; they erode the author's credibility.
To master the Praxis Core Writing exam, you must stop viewing pronoun rules as arbitrary trivia and start seeing them as the mechanical tolerances of clear thought. Let's dismantle the machinery of pronouns, inspect how they function under stress, and learn how to reassemble them with absolute precision.
A pronoun is a word used to stand in for or replace a noun in a sentence. It exists so we do not have to write mechanically repetitive sentences like, "The teacher graded the teacher's papers while the teacher drank the teacher's coffee."
The specific noun that a pronoun replaces or refers to is called the antecedent of the pronoun. The pronoun is tied to its antecedent by a rigid mathematical relationship known as agreement.
Understanding this relationship requires us to first identify the point of view expressed by the pronoun, which is known as pronoun person.
- First-person pronouns represent the speaker or writer. They include I, me, my, we, us, and our.
- Second-person pronouns directly address the reader or listener. They include you, your, and yours.
- Third-person pronouns refer to an outside person, place, or thing being discussed. They include he, him, she, her, it, they, and them.
Just as a replacement gear must perfectly match the size and threading of the gear it replaces, a pronoun must be in total alignment with its antecedent.
A pronoun must agree with its antecedent in person. A pronoun shift error occurs when a writer changes person or number within a sentence unnecessarily. For example, formal academic writing typically avoids unnecessary pronoun shifts from the third person to the second person.
- Error: "If a student wants to pass the Praxis, you must study." (Shifts from third-person student to second-person you).
- Correction: "If a student wants to pass the Praxis, he or she must study."
A pronoun must agree with its antecedent in gender. (e.g., matching she with Sarah, or it with the committee).
Crucially, a pronoun must agree with its antecedent in number. A singular antecedent requires a singular pronoun, and a plural antecedent requires a plural pronoun. This seems simple until you encounter the complex boundary conditions of the English language.
Compound Antecedents
When antecedents are joined by conjunctions, the rules of number agreement depend entirely on the conjunction used:
- Two or more singular antecedents joined by the word "and" require a plural pronoun.
- Example: "The principal and the counselor submitted their reports." (1 + 1 = 2, making it plural).
- When singular antecedents are joined by the word "or" or "nor", the agreeing pronoun must be singular.
- Example: "Neither the principal nor the counselor submitted his report." (You are choosing one or the other, so it remains singular).
- When a singular antecedent and a plural antecedent are joined by "or" or "nor", the pronoun agrees in number with the closer antecedent.
- Example: "Neither the principal nor the teachers submitted their reports." (Because teachers is physically closer to the pronoun, the pronoun becomes plural).
Indefinite Pronouns
Words like everyone, anybody, and each feel plural in our minds. If I say "everyone is here," you picture a room full of people. However, grammatically, the indefinite pronouns "everyone", "anybody", and "each" require singular pronouns. They operate like the phrase "every single one."
- Error: "Each of the students must bring their permission slip."
- Correction: "Each of the students must bring his or her permission slip."
Collective Nouns
Collective nouns (like faculty, committee, class, or team) refer to a group of individuals. Does a collective noun take a singular or a plural pronoun? The answer is: Watch what the group is doing.
- Collective nouns require singular pronouns when the noun refers to the group as a single cohesive unit acting together.
- Example: "The faculty cast its unanimous vote."
- Collective nouns require plural pronouns when the noun refers to the individual members of the group acting separately.
- Example: "The faculty gathered their briefcases and walked to different cars."
Pronoun case refers to the form a pronoun takes depending on the grammatical function of the pronoun in a sentence. Think of case as the uniform the pronoun wears depending on its job. Is it doing the work (subject), receiving the work (object), or owning the work (possessive)?
| Case | Grammatical Function | Pronoun Roster |
|---|---|---|
| Subjective | Subject of a sentence, subject of a clause, or following a linking verb. | I, you, he, she, it, we, they, who |
| Objective | Direct object, indirect object, or object of a preposition. | me, you, him, her, it, us, them, whom |
| Possessive | Indicates ownership or possession. | my, mine, your, yours, his, her, hers, its, our, ours, their, theirs, whose |
Let's look at how these rules operate under testing conditions.
The Subjective Case
Subjective case pronouns function as the subject of a sentence ("She wrote the lesson plan") or as the subject of a clause ("I know that he will pass").
There are two highly tested edge cases for the subjective case:
- Linking Verbs: A pronoun following a linking verb should be in the subjective case. A linking verb (like is, am, are, was, were) acts as an equals sign. Therefore, what follows it must match the subject.
- Example: "The winner of the Teacher of the Year award is she." (Not her).
- Compound Subjects: When a pronoun is part of a compound subject, the subjective case must be used.
- Example: "Mr. Davis and I graded the exams." (Remove "Mr. Davis and" to test it: you wouldn't say "Me graded the exams.")
The Objective Case
Objective case pronouns function as the direct object of a verb (receiving the action directly), the indirect object of a verb (receiving the direct object), or the object of a preposition (following words like to, for, with, between).
- Compound Objects: When a pronoun is part of a compound object, the objective case must be used.
- Example: "The superintendent assigned the new curriculum to Mrs. Lee and me." (Remove "Mrs. Lee and" to test it: you wouldn't say "assigned the curriculum to I").
Appositives and Pronoun Case
An appositive is a noun phrase placed right next to another noun to rename or describe it. An appositive pronoun must be in the exact same case as the noun the appositive renames.
- Subjective example: "We teachers love a quiet classroom." (We renames the subject teachers).
- Objective example: "The district provides resources for us teachers." (Us renames the object of the preposition teachers).
The Litmus Test: Who vs. Whom
Few things paralyze a writer like deciding between who and whom. The Praxis tests this rigorously, but the physics of it are beautifully simple.
- The pronoun "who" is a subjective case pronoun. The pronoun "who" performs the action of the verb in a clause. (Substitute he, she, or they to test it).
- The pronoun "whom" is an objective case pronoun. The pronoun "whom" receives the action of the verb in a clause. (Substitute him, her, or them to test it).
The Try-It-Out Method: "The teacher [who/whom] I admire is retiring." Isolate the clause: I admire [who/whom]. You would say "I admire him." Because him is objective, the correct choice is whom. The sentence becomes: "The teacher whom I admire is retiring."
Pronouns are lightweight replacements, but if the reader cannot instantly calculate exactly which noun the pronoun replaces, the communication fails.
A vague pronoun error occurs when a pronoun lacks a clear antecedent. A vague pronoun error can be corrected by replacing the vague pronoun with a specific noun. The Praxis Writing exam tests four specific variations of this structural failure:
- Ambiguous pronoun reference happens when a pronoun could refer to more than one possible antecedent in a sentence.
- Error: "When Sarah handed the student her essay, she smiled." (Who smiled? Sarah or the student?)
- Implied pronoun reference happens when a pronoun refers to an antecedent that is suggested rather than explicitly stated.
- Error: "In the administration building, they enforce the dress code." (Who is they? Administrators are implied, but the noun administrators is entirely missing from the sentence).
- Broad pronoun reference occurs when a pronoun refers to an entire preceding clause or sentence rather than a specific noun.
- Error: "The projector broke during my observation, which was incredibly stressful." (What does which refer to? The projector? The observation? The fact that it broke?)
- The pronouns "it", "this", "that", and "which" are frequently involved in broad pronoun reference errors. Whenever you write "This means that...", ensure "This" refers to a specific, singular noun, not a general concept.
Our final category involves pronouns that end in the suffix "-self" or "-selves".
Reflexive and intensive pronouns include myself, yourself, himself, herself, itself, ourselves, yourselves, and themselves.
(Note on standard English: The words "hisself" and "theirselves" are nonstandard words and are considered grammatically incorrect in formal writing. Never choose them on the Praxis).
Despite sharing the exact same vocabulary list, intensive and reflexive pronouns perform two entirely different grammatical functions.
The Megaphone: Intensive Pronouns
An intensive pronoun is used exclusively to emphasize a preceding noun or pronoun. It exists only to turn up the volume. Because it is merely for emphasis, an intensive pronoun can be removed from a sentence without changing the core meaning of the sentence.
- Example: "The principal himself audited the gradebook." (If you remove himself, the sentence still means the exact same thing: The principal audited the gradebook).
The Mirror: Reflexive Pronouns
A reflexive pronoun is used when the subject and object of a sentence are the exact same entity. The action of the verb reflects back onto the subject. Because it acts as the object of the sentence, a reflexive pronoun is essential to the grammatical completeness of its sentence.
- Example: "The young student taught himself to read." (If you remove himself, the sentence breaks: "The young student taught to read." Taught whom?)
The Cardinal Rule of "-self" Pronouns
There is a rising, unfortunate trend in corporate and academic communication to use "-self" pronouns to sound more formal or polite. ("Please email your lesson plans to Mr. Adams or myself.") This is grammatically catastrophic.
An intensive pronoun cannot be used as the subject of a sentence. Furthermore, a reflexive pronoun cannot be used as the subject of a sentence. They must always have an antecedent to emphasize or reflect back upon.
- Error: "Myself and the other teachers will chaperone the dance."
- Correction: "The other teachers and I will chaperone the dance."
Language is built on these exact tolerances. When you master agreement, case, and clarity, you are not merely preparing to pass a licensing exam. You are mastering the mechanics of professional thought, ensuring that your future students, colleagues, and parents receive your ideas exactly as you designed them.